Friday, September 25, 2020
US flag

Grade 5 Common Core math: Joshua’s garden

The following constructed response question, explained here in hopes of helping fifth-grade students and their parents in Maryland and Illinois prepare for the PARCC test near the end of this school year, appears on the released version of PARCC’s Spring 2015 “PBA” (performance-based assessment) for grade 5 math:

Joshua planted carrots and peas in his garden.

a drawing (diagram, model) of the garden Joshua planted

Use the model to write and solve an equation that shows how much larger the pea section of the garden is than the carrot section of the garden. Enter your equation and your solution in the space provided.


What color do you think the carrots were in Joshua’s garden?

Answer and references

Correct answer: C = 3/16. P = 1/4. P – C = 1/16.

PARCC evidence statement(s) tested: 5.D.1, according to the PARCC alignment document.

Solve multi-step contextual word problems with degree of difficulty appropriate to Grade 5, requiring application of knowledge and skills articulated in Type I, Sub-Claim A Evidence Statements.

The evidence statement above references Math Practice 4 in the Common Core: Model with mathematics.

Mathematically proficient students can apply the mathematics they know to solve problems arising in everyday life, society, and the workplace. In early grades, this might be as simple as writing an addition equation to describe a situation. In middle grades, a student might apply proportional reasoning to plan a school event or analyze a problem in the community. By high school, a student might use geometry to solve a design problem or use a function to describe how one quantity of interest depends on another. Mathematically proficient students who can apply what they know are comfortable making assumptions and approximations to simplify a complicated situation, realizing that these may need revision later. They are able to identify important quantities in a practical situation and map their relationships using such tools as diagrams, two-way tables, graphs, flowcharts and formulas. They can analyze those relationships mathematically to draw conclusions. They routinely interpret their mathematical results in the context of the situation and reflect on whether the results make sense, possibly improving the model if it has not served its purpose.

The evidence statement requires students to apply knowledge of mathematics in real-world problems appropriate to Grade 5 math standards in the Common Core, including standard 5.NF.A.2, which says students should be able to

Solve word problems involving addition and subtraction of fractions referring to the same whole, including cases of unlike denominators, e.g., by using visual fraction models or equations to represent the problem. Use benchmark fractions and number sense of fractions to estimate mentally and assess the reasonableness of answers. For example, recognize an incorrect result 2/5 + 1/2 = 3/7, by observing that 3/7 < 1/2.

or 5.NF.B.4.A, which says students should be able to

Find the area of a rectangle with fractional side lengths by tiling it with unit squares of the appropriate unit fraction side lengths, and show that the area is the same as would be found by multiplying the side lengths. Multiply fractional side lengths to find areas of rectangles, and represent fraction products as rectangular areas.

Example solution strategy (there are others)

Because the left side of the garden measures 1 yard and it’s divided into 4 equal sections, the length of each section is 9 inches, and each little square represents 9 × 9 = 81 square inches in area in the model as drawn. Since the carrot section has 3 little squares, its area, represented by C, is

C = (3)(81) = 243\;\textrm{square inches}

Turning to the pea section of Joshua’s garden, I see each side is the same length as two sides of the little squares, which I know are 9 inches each. The length of a side of the pea section is therefore 18 inches, and the area of the pea section, represented by P, is

P = (18)(18) = 324\;\textrm{square inches}

I am asked how much bigger the pea section is than the carrot section, which means I have to subtract C from P to find the answer:

\textrm{Difference in area} = P - C
324 - 243 = 81\;\textrm{square inches}

Resources for further study

Materials on working with fractions can be found almost anywhere on the Internet. Purple Math, developed by Elizabeth Stapel, a math teacher from the St Louis area, has an entire series devoted to working with fractions, as intended in this problem.

Analysis of this question and online accessibility

Students don’t need knowledge of substantial aspects of the math standards in the Grade 5, Number & Operations—Fractions section of the Common Core to solve the problem, unless they decide to use fractions, which isn’t the only approach. Because knowledge of those specific fifth-grade standards isn’t necessary to solve the problem as given—see my sample solution, which doesn’t have a fraction anywhere in sight—and because knowledge of the standards must be both necessary and sufficient to address the question if we’re claiming the question is aligned to the learning standard, this question is largely out of alignment with the Common Core.

As a result, a parent or teacher can base no useful conclusions about how well students understand modeling with fractions, which is what the evidence statement says this question measures, on any data that includes scores on this question.

The question can be delivered online and would yield performance statistics that are as valid as those obtained from paper-and-pencil test-takers. However, online test-takers may have difficulty with the equation editor, and if they have such difficulty, they may not be able to type in all the logic and reasoning needed to receive full credit (3 points) for this question.

I remind students, as I have in the past, when the equation editor pops up for a question, take a little extra time to make sure you:

  • Type in all the logic and reasoning you used when solving the problem
  • Transfer all your work from scratch paper to the computer

No special accommodation challenges can be identified with this question, so the question is considered fair.

Real-world setting

Rachel Weill and her husband, David Levitt, in San Anselmo, California, have two children, one 11- and the other 7-years-old. When those kids get home from school, they can’t wait to get fresh vegetables and fruit from the garden they’ve planted in their own backyard, Sunset reports.

“They constantly bring in food at random times, wanting to make a salad,” Ms Weill says. “And when they have friends over, they like to show off the garden.”

Among the veggies she recommends planting are carrots and snap peas, just like Joshua in the math problem here.

She hired a contractor to build four raised beds of untreated redwood into the hillside and secured those boxes with long bolts. Then she anchored the beds to the ground with cement. She grew the carrots from seed, and everything else was started in a nursery, she said.

Paul Katula is the executive editor of the Voxitatis Research Foundation, which publishes this blog. For more information, see the About page.

Recent posts

New youth forum talks virtual learning in Md.

Virtual learning thoughts from a Md. HS: It can work and keeps kids safe, but it ends up being harder (you can't just ask a teacher if you don't understand).

IL brings 1000s back to school for SAT exam

Many IL seniors went back to their school buildings today to make up the SAT exam, which they missed last spring as juniors due to the pandemic.

How citizens prefer to fund environmental action

Growing demand for countries to combat climate change, less consensus on how to fund it. New study offers insight from the US, UK, Germany, France.

Student news roundup, Illinois, Sept. 21

The death of The Notorious RBG, foreign exchange student from France, live streaming plays, BLM, and (of course) remote learning.

Fewer kindergartners, more college drop-outs

The nation has experienced an increase in college drop-outs, esp. among low-income families, and an explainable decrease in kindergarten enrollment.

Tim Kaine talks to Fairfax Co. seniors

In Virginia, protesters intimidated citizens at an early voting center in Fairfax Co. Sen. Tim Kaine talks about voting to students.

Obituary: Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg

The death of Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg is certain to bring a political battle between the president, the Senate, and Democrats.

Students help in wake of Gulf Coast storms

Hurricane victims in the South got some much needed help from students at one Louisiana school. Laura and Sally have been very destructive.

Scientific American endorses a candidate

It's rare that a science journal would endorse a presidential candidate, but it has happened, due mainly to Pres. Trump's rejection of science.

Student news roundup, Maryland, Sept. 16

The pandemic reveals much more about us than our unpreparedness for virtual learning; Md. students look at healthcare and choices about schooling.

Smoke from Calif. paints the East Coast sun

The sunrise this morning in Baltimore and Chicago was cooled by smoke from the Calif. wildfires, which created a thick haze aloft.