Tuesday, January 21, 2020
US flag

Minn. groups file transgender bathroom complaint

A federal court in Minnesota received a complaint that a school’s rule to allow a transgender girl to change in a girls’ locker room is violating the privacy rights of a girl who, lawyers claim, feels as though she can’t play basketball if it means she has to change in the presence of the transgender girl, the Minneapolis Star-Tribune reports.


Alexander Wilson HS girls’ basketball, 1953 (N.C. Digital Heritage Center / Flickr CC)

Federal judges across the country have rejected most arguments from school districts that claim they don’t have to follow recent guidance from the US Department of Education to allow unfettered access to bathrooms and locker rooms in schools to students based on their gender identity, even if it differs from their biological sex. But groups continue to fight against the guidance, and now a new argument from the anti-transgender camp has surfaced.

A nonprofit advocacy group has thrust itself into one case. Asserting the claim that the Fourth Amendment, which basically means that “each man’s home is his castle,” gives girls the right not to have to expose their bodies at the request of the school in a situation in which they don’t want to, the Alliance Defending Freedom says that enforcing the guidance infringes on the rights of girls in the locker room or bathroom.

The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized. (4th Amendment)

The part about “secure in their persons” has been narrowly interpreted to provide a right of privacy in 20th-century cases in the Supreme Court. But the alliance, a nonprofit that tends to fight for conservative issues, especially about abortion, nullifies its own argument by taking part in this case, known as Privacy Matters v US Department of Education.

Look, you can’t with one group of lawyers say that women’s privacy can be violated by the government forcing certain types of invasive ultrasounds and other procedures on them that are medically unnecessary just because they want an abortion and, with another group of lawyers, say that girls in schools have a right to privacy in a locker room and shouldn’t be compelled to undress in front of a transgender girl.

The hypocrisy is staggering, but it may not matter. The Supreme Court is likely to hear a Virginia case during this term involving this very issue, which will supersede any orders in this case and several others that grant or restrict the access transgender students have to bathrooms and changing rooms in schools and direct those schools on the lawful handling of these individual cases once and for all.

Of course, a tied Supreme Court—right now, we have an even number of justices, despite President Barack Obama’s nomination of a replacement justice—would fail to establish a precedent, and we could be right back where we are now, with different schools treating the issue very differently and federal courts not knowing what to make of it.

Paul Katula is the executive editor of the Voxitatis Research Foundation, which publishes this blog. For more information, see the About page.

Recent posts

Feds boost Bay funding

Restoration efforts in the Chesapeake Bay watershed received a boost in federal funding in the budget Congress passed last month.

Md. & IL bands perform on New Year’s in...

Bands from IL and Md. once again entertained thousands of people who lined the streets of London and Rome on New Year's Day.

Howard Co. sounds an under-staffing alarm

Teachers in a Md. district have filed a grievance over missing planning and lunch periods and, as a result, putting the most vulnerable students at risk.

Top 11 school stories of 2019

We find these 11 stories to have the greatest potential for influencing activity and direction in schools for the near future.

Girls’ volleyball champs in Illinois

We congratulate the Illinois state champions in girls' volleyball: Newark, St Teresa, Sterling, & Benet Academy.

A weekend of ‘band geeks’ across America

The musical Band Geeks was in performance at a MD high school, just as marching bands from across America named a national champion.

2 dead, 3 wounded in Calif. school shooting

Another school shooting has resulted in the death of 2 California high school students. The suspect shot himself and is in custody.

Mercury makes a transit; next in 2032

A transit of Mercury occurred today and was visible from the US, provided you had sunny skies. It was one of longest possible transits.

On the Naperville BWW racist incident

A racist incident at a Naperville, IL, sports bar indicates that the threads of racism are strong, perhaps as strong as ever.

IL bill could excuse absences to vote

A proposed law in IL could give students up to two hours during the school day so they could vote in the upcoming election.

Loan forgiveness gains some bipartisan support

One Republican from GA, who used to work under Betsy DeVos at the US Education Dept, offers a plan to forgive some student loan debt.