Thursday, November 14, 2019
US flag

SCOTUS won’t hear Kan. science/atheism case

The Supreme Court of the United States yesterday declined to hear a case from Kansas in which plaintiffs claimed the science standards adopted by the state in 2013 forced students to become atheists, the Associated Press reports.

The Supreme Court decision not to hear the case was delivered without comment. A group of parents and students, who oppose the new science standards, known as the Next Generation Science Standards, calls itself Citizens for Objective Public Education.

In denying the appeal from the US Court of Appeals for the 10th Circuit, the Supreme Court had to agree that the students and parents were not harmed in any way by the teaching of science as found in the NGSS.

COPE claimed in its original complaint that science education in Kansas schools was “indoctrinating impressionable young minds,” beginning at age 5 or 6, when those impressionable minds “lack the cognitive or mental development and scientific, mathematical, philosophical and theological sophistication necessary to enable them to critically analyze and question any of the information presented and to reach their own informed decision about what to believe about ultimate questions fundamental to all religions.”

What a mouthful. Anyway, the trial court and a three-judge panel for the 10th Circuit said that was too abstract. It could never, based on that evidence, prove that the science standards violated students’ rights under the First Amendment, namely the right to be free of an establishment of religion by the school and the right to practice any religion freely.

Still, COPE tried, dragging out that old “intelligent design” argument that masquerades, not so subtly, as creationism: “Because living systems appear to be ‘brilliantly’ and ‘superbly’ ‘designed for a purpose’ by a ‘sentient’ designer and because of religious training and belief acquired from family and the community, young children bring to public schools teleological conceptions of the natural world which conflict with the tenets of the materialistic/atheistic Orthodoxy,” which is what COPE claimed the NGSS were teaching.

By forcing students to answer questions like, “Where do we come from?” the group felt the schools were establishing a religion called atheism. By defying what students were taught at home, which is that a being in their dreams created the whole universe, the schools were denying students the right to practice their religion freely.

The argument just staggers my mind. I am stopped cold in my tracks. So was the 10th Circuit.

The Standards do not condemn any or all religions and do not target religious believers for disfavored treatment. And COPE offers only threadbare assertions that the Standards intend to promote a non-religious worldview. Thus, COPE’s allegations regarding adoption amount to psychological consequences produced by observation of conduct with which it disagrees.

That’s not good enough, and the judgment of the trial court was affirmed. Case closed.

A few other points: First, COPE can argue that the NGSS advance worldviews that differ from those held by the families of the students who were supposedly injured. But in their argument, the court found that the group failed to show that the standards condemn any religion or send any message of endorsement. If that could be shown, the NGSS would run afoul of the First Amendment, but it wasn’t shown.

Finally, individual school districts can choose not to use any curriculum that supports the NGSS. Because of this option at the local level, COPE is only speculating that injury will be caused, and that speculation does not give them standing in a lawsuit against the state school board. In fact, districts can include the alternative (religious) worldviews that COPE holds if they so choose, according to the court:

The Standards themselves encourage districts to teach the limits of scientific knowledge. They state that students should “develop an understanding that … science and engineering … are human endeavors,” and that some science- or engineering-related questions have “moral … underpinnings that vary across cultures,” the answers to which are “not solved by scientific and engineering methods alone.” Moreover, the Kansas NGSS Review Committee expressly recommends that districts “push beyond these standards” as they develop curricula. Because the Standards expressly recommend objective curricula, and the committee advises districts to add to the Standards, districts may choose to delve deeper into the limitations of the scientific method or to teach alternative origins theories.

Paul Katula is the executive editor of the Voxitatis Research Foundation, which publishes this blog. For more information, see the About page.

Recent posts

Mercury makes a transit; next in 2032

A transit of Mercury occurred today and was visible from the US, provided you had sunny skies. It was one of longest possible transits.

On the Naperville BWW racist incident

A racist incident at a Naperville, IL, sports bar indicates that the threads of racism are strong, perhaps as strong as ever.

IL bill could excuse absences to vote

A proposed law in IL could give students up to two hours during the school day so they could vote in the upcoming election.

Loan forgiveness gains some bipartisan support

One Republican from GA, who used to work under Betsy DeVos at the US Education Dept, offers a plan to forgive some student loan debt.

A band teacher is IL Teacher of the Year

IL named a band teacher the 2020 Teacher of the Year on Oct. 19. He individualizes music instruction and shares his work with 1000s.

‘Little Shop of Horrors’ bookends Halloween

Several high schools have decided to add a little spook to their musical stages in this season of Halloween. Music makes it happen.

New IL law ensures inclusion of LGBTQ+

A law will take effect next school year in IL that will require students to study LGBTQ history as part of the social studies curriculum.

MoCo doubles down on summer learning loss

Research is at least equivocal about summer learning loss, but maybe there's something to a new plan in Montgomery County, Md.

Downers North lights up the gym for Beth

Ongoing fundraising drives for a Downers Grove N. volleyball player killed by an intoxicated driver in Feb. are going strong in this western suburb.

High-payroll Yankees don’t make World Series

The World Series begins Tuesday, but some of the playoff games can teach us valuable things about youth sports, investment, etc.

Chicago teacher strike enters calendar week 2

Chicago teachers strike for the 3rd day Monday; the union wants smaller class sizes and support for paraprofessionals.