Tuesday, November 12, 2019
US flag

Federal judge lectures lawyer on sacred music

The US Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit will issue a ruling within three months in a case involving a Christmas show that has been produced at an Indiana high school for more than four decades but used to include a live nativity scene that a district court found unconstitutional, Courthouse News reports.

The 90-minute Christmas show at Concord High School in Elkhart also included, in the past, a reading of passages from the Bible telling the story of Jesus Christ’s birth. Mannequins are now used for the nativity scene, following verbal requests from the superintendent. The Bible reading has also been cut back and Kwanzaa and Hanukkah songs have been added to the show.

But although the constitutionality of an endorsement of one religion in a “Christmas” show can’t just be reduced to a formula or dressed up with Jewish or other traditions, a district judge in March said those 2015 modifications were enough.

In October, the American Civil Liberties Union, representing the Freedom from Religion Foundation, was before the Seventh Circuit to appeal that ruling, arguing first that verbal instructions from the superintendent don’t sufficiently replace a formal written policy and, second, that the strong desire from the school community—evidenced by a Facebook poll and large standing ovations during the nativity scene—to revive that tradition could easily make the school venture into unconstitutional waters again.

Performance of sacred music in public high schools

Having studied music at a major public university, I can say that religious music is a huge part of our history. One can’t study four-part voice leading, for instance, without studying the work of JS Bach, and most of his extensive body of work includes religious text. One can’t study choral literature without reading some religious texts.

But ACLU lawyer Gavin Rose told the Seventh Circuit he wasn’t familiar with that part of music history, and that brought bewilderment from the three-judge panel. He did allow, however, that there’s a gray area between performance of religious music in a school play, as this is, and the performance of religious music in a worship service.

Still, he added, this case is different. “Whatever it means to perform religious music in a secular fashion, that is not what this is,” he was quoted as saying. His main argument is that all music students—about half the Concord student population—are required to be a part of the show.

“What about Jesus Christ Superstar as the high school musical?” Judge Diane Sykes asked him. “What about a performance of Bach’s St Matthew’s Passion?” Judge Frank Easterbrook was quoted as asking. “I have to admit, your Honor, I am not familiar with the piece,” the attorney answered, which brought an unusual look from the judge.

“Oh dear, that is a problem,” Judge Easterbrook was quoted as saying. “Well let me just tell you, that during the St Matthew’s Passion, a character called the Evangelist reads the text of the Gospel of St Matthew, and then there are lots of other religious figures. It’s one of the most venerated pieces in the history of music. Not being familiar with it is hard for me to understand.”

Paul Katula is the executive editor of the Voxitatis Research Foundation, which publishes this blog. For more information, see the About page.

Recent posts

Mercury makes a transit; next in 2032

A transit of Mercury occurred today and was visible from the US, provided you had sunny skies. It was one of longest possible transits.

On the Naperville BWW racist incident

A racist incident at a Naperville, IL, sports bar indicates that the threads of racism are strong, perhaps as strong as ever.

IL bill could excuse absences to vote

A proposed law in IL could give students up to two hours during the school day so they could vote in the upcoming election.

Loan forgiveness gains some bipartisan support

One Republican from GA, who used to work under Betsy DeVos at the US Education Dept, offers a plan to forgive some student loan debt.

A band teacher is IL Teacher of the Year

IL named a band teacher the 2020 Teacher of the Year on Oct. 19. He individualizes music instruction and shares his work with 1000s.

‘Little Shop of Horrors’ bookends Halloween

Several high schools have decided to add a little spook to their musical stages in this season of Halloween. Music makes it happen.

New IL law ensures inclusion of LGBTQ+

A law will take effect next school year in IL that will require students to study LGBTQ history as part of the social studies curriculum.

MoCo doubles down on summer learning loss

Research is at least equivocal about summer learning loss, but maybe there's something to a new plan in Montgomery County, Md.

Downers North lights up the gym for Beth

Ongoing fundraising drives for a Downers Grove N. volleyball player killed by an intoxicated driver in Feb. are going strong in this western suburb.

High-payroll Yankees don’t make World Series

The World Series begins Tuesday, but some of the playoff games can teach us valuable things about youth sports, investment, etc.

Chicago teacher strike enters calendar week 2

Chicago teachers strike for the 3rd day Monday; the union wants smaller class sizes and support for paraprofessionals.