Sunday, December 8, 2019
US flag

Judge won’t stop a transgender policy in Dist. 211

A federal judge in Chicago last week refused to order Township High School District 211, based in Palatine, Illinois, to suspend its policy on bathroom use by transgender students, saying that anti-discrimination laws that have been on the books for decades do apply to student whose gender identity isn’t conventional, the Associated Press reports.

The district’s policy, forged in the spotlight of the nation from another federal lawsuit two years ago, is one that respects the rights of all students, District 211 Superintendent Daniel Cates said in a letter to district families last month. “The Illinois Department of Human Rights has already dismissed this case, stating there was no evidence of discrimination,” he wrote. “Still today, these matters divide communities across the nation.”

Despite a nation divided over this issue, students and staff at the district’s five high schools “are not divided on this issue,” he wrote. “Every day in our schools, transgender students have full access to the bathrooms of their identified gender. Each day, transgender students use the locker room of their identified gender. Some seek more private accommodations, and those are provided as well.”


Aerial view of Palatine High School in District 211 (school district via YouTube)

US District Judge Jorge Alonso agreed and struck a blow to more than 50 families who had joined a lawsuit aimed at ending the policy and forcing the district to force transgender students to use bathrooms based on their biological sex. His 15-page opinion said courts have consistently and “correctly recognized” that “federal protections against sex discrimination are substantially broader than based only on genitalia or chromosome.”

Since that original case, I have consistently held that protections need to be extended to transgender students, but I have differed slightly with this opinion on these pages in that the word “sex,” which is the technical word in the law, to a biological scientist like myself, refers to the presence of a Y chromosome in the cells of the body. Legally, Congress should act to reword Title IX and similar statutes to include our new understanding of sex—i.e., gender—because I believe everyone now understands that protections should extend beyond XX or XY classifications. In the meantime, though, courts will have to step in to interpret Title IX, which is far superior to the US Education Department redefining “sex” when Congress, and Congress alone, is responsible for writing the laws.

Judge Alonso’s refusal to issue a temporary injunction doesn’t mean the families have lost the case, but it does indicate that he believes their principle claim that the policy infringes on the rights of non-transgender students lacks merit, based on the evidence presented before the case can be heard in a trial. Often after such a ruling, cases are dropped.

And the judge is backed by recent rulings from the Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals in Chicago. In May, that court ruled that a transgender student in Wisconsin, who identifies as a boy despite looking like a girl, should be allowed to use the boys’ bathroom at his high school. The court found that the privacy rights of other students in the bathroom were no more at risk from the presence of a transgender student in the bathroom than they would be from other students who were curious and started peering around.

That guidance from the higher court, Judge Alonso wrote, “is now clear, and binding.”

Paul Katula is the executive editor of the Voxitatis Research Foundation, which publishes this blog. For more information, see the About page.

Recent posts

Girls’ volleyball champs in Illinois

We congratulate the Illinois state champions in girls' volleyball: Newark, St Teresa, Sterling, & Benet Academy.

A weekend of ‘band geeks’ across America

The musical Band Geeks was in performance at a MD high school, just as marching bands from across America named a national champion.

2 dead, 3 wounded in Calif. school shooting

Another school shooting has resulted in the death of 2 California high school students. The suspect shot himself and is in custody.

Mercury makes a transit; next in 2032

A transit of Mercury occurred today and was visible from the US, provided you had sunny skies. It was one of longest possible transits.

On the Naperville BWW racist incident

A racist incident at a Naperville, IL, sports bar indicates that the threads of racism are strong, perhaps as strong as ever.

IL bill could excuse absences to vote

A proposed law in IL could give students up to two hours during the school day so they could vote in the upcoming election.

Loan forgiveness gains some bipartisan support

One Republican from GA, who used to work under Betsy DeVos at the US Education Dept, offers a plan to forgive some student loan debt.

A band teacher is IL Teacher of the Year

IL named a band teacher the 2020 Teacher of the Year on Oct. 19. He individualizes music instruction and shares his work with 1000s.

‘Little Shop of Horrors’ bookends Halloween

Several high schools have decided to add a little spook to their musical stages in this season of Halloween. Music makes it happen.

New IL law ensures inclusion of LGBTQ+

A law will take effect next school year in IL that will require students to study LGBTQ history as part of the social studies curriculum.

MoCo doubles down on summer learning loss

Research is at least equivocal about summer learning loss, but maybe there's something to a new plan in Montgomery County, Md.